April 20, 2019 at 11:04 pm #246152
I am unable to get any email notifications, if this feature does not actually work then this camera is absolutely useless to me.
I have my own local smtp mail server, my poe wired Reolink cameras are able to send me email notifications, but the Argus Pro does not, not even the test-message when setting up the configuration on the camera via the android Reolink app.
Is this a known issue?April 21, 2019 at 5:55 am #246422
I have 3 Argus 2 cameras and they all send emails fine... but I am sending them to a gmail account.
Just as a test... I would set up a temp gmail account and try that to see if it something on your end or with the camera. You say your email server is local... is it in a DMZ... do you manage your own Firewall? Can you see traffic on port 25?
Hope that helps.
BillApril 21, 2019 at 6:30 am #246430
Yours is an Argus 2, I'm thinking the issue could be with my model, Argus Pro.
The wired Reolinks are all on the same subnet and are sending notification emails fine. It is a routed subnet all running out of a Juniper PoE switch, everything is configured correctly and working as it should. If there was an issue then none of the other Reolink models would be sending emails. I have used the exact same configuration as in the wired reolinks.
The problem is most definitely with the Argus, it just doesn't do anything with local smtp emails it appears, I'm going to have to Wireshark it via mirror-port and see if it in fact even attempts to do anything SMTP relative. I do have a strong suspicion that email notifications simply do not work with local SMTP because as far as I can tell these Argus cameras are designed to rely on an open internet connection if one wants to access/configure them via the windows client, someone stated in a review that the Argus cameras send the feed to a Reolink server and then the windows client gets the feed from the Reolink server, if this is indeed the case with the Argus range then this is something which people should be made aware of.
I will just for arguments sake create a temporary gmail account to see if that works, however that still doesn't resolve the issue in hand, I have no intention of putting this camera online or to use a 3rd party online email server, it would defeat the purpose of the system being self-contained and not relying on an internet connection to keep me notified.
If it isn't too much to ask Bill, I would love to know if you are able to send email notifications from your Argus 2 to a local SMTP server? you could use minirelay http://www.netvicious.com/miniRelay/miniRelay.zip, and see if Argus 2 actually connects to the relay even.April 21, 2019 at 7:03 am #246446
My firmware version is: 0530_94_107_24
Unable to find any info on firmware releases for the Argus Pro.April 21, 2019 at 7:49 am #246466
Ok, I have found the issue, the problem is that the battery powered reolink cameras do all their notifications via the internet. So it does appear that Argus range of cameras do NOT support local smtp. This is a major security risk and should be flagged.
So it means this camera is not for me and I will now have to request a refund. Why don't these manufacturers simply state on their marketing ”INTERNET REQUIRED FOR NOTIFICATIONS”.
I have wasted the best part of a couple of days trying to get this to work when it was never going to work in the first place!April 21, 2019 at 8:14 am #246476
What are your specific security concerns? Just don't want the camera's connected to the Inet?
April 21, 2019 at 10:32 am #246527
- This reply was modified 5 months ago by Bill Verdon.
Tongue-in-cheek I would say the concerns are the same as Trump, which is why he banned Huawei, Hikvision and Dahua from government installations, and rightly so, I'm guessing many more to get on that list.
The problem is that the codebase is closed-source. IoT devices are already a nightmare in general. Sophos did a study on it all recently and detailed the thousands of attack vectors which people are introducing into their homes.
A ”security” product should take SECURITY seriously and be able to function without having to ”dial the manufacturer”. Understandably these devices are designed to just work for the average consumer, but not all consumers are 'average’, security companies should make certain that functionality is present which permits a consumer to operate a network device in a private network.
Also take into consideration the possibility if a product becomes end-of-line in a few years, and those 'dial the manufacturer’ servers decide to go offline, a product becomes useless on the most part. This has happened to countless products over the years across all departments.
The above is just a small list of reasons.
For I personally it is simply the fact that I have my security running in an offline network with GSM integration, no greater internet (cable/adsl) reliance whatsoever. The other Reolink cameras do email notifications just fine but I don't use that for I have them running as Onvif cameras working under Milestone. The Argus is not a 24/7 recording camera, thus I have to rely on notifications, but if those notifications are not possible offline, then the product is crippled, take for example if the phone-line goes off for a few hours due to telecom works down the road or if the internet goes off because of some ISP routing issues... it means security notifications go off, and that is something which 'average’ consumers just dont think about until it happens.
It is rather unfortunate, as the Argus Pro is actually quite a nice technical achievement as a package.April 22, 2019 at 10:15 am #247092
Yes, the notification relies on the internet, you will not receive the notification if you disable the internet. Just like you have to open the network to receive notifications from other apps on your phone. I can understand your concerns about security issues. But the most basic thing about a security company is to protect the privacy of customers and ensure product safety.
Sorry that the battery-powered camera can only record when motion detected in order to save power. Argus Pro is a smart and mature camera, which does not have a security risk. But if you've stuck to return it, we will respect your choice and help you return it. If you have problems during the operation, you can send an email to email@example.com. Our technical support will check it for you soon. Thank you for supporting Reolink.April 22, 2019 at 7:21 pm #247264
What you need to understand about ”Security” is that unless you have international peer review and sign-off by an established global compliance institution of your security and privacy practices, then your word is as good as anyone else who claims ”we are 100% secure”. If you need more information on such standards/certifications, please contact Sophos/McAfee/Symantec for further guidance on how to obtain such certification.
In the meantime, as a security product manufacturer, you must understand that not everyone will work their devices on open internet connections, even with port forwarding between specific IP addresses, as it is another potential attack vector, assume DDOS etc.
The Argus range requires IP connectivity but because you are relying on communication with Reolink servers only, you are effectively crippling the device for those who want to use such devices on closed networks. Imagine if you did this on all your other Reolink cameras? Most people would not purchase them if that were the case and made public!
Point of fact is that if you gave the Argus the same local-network connectivity without relying on Reolink servers as your other products, then the Argus would be a complete product covering both audiences, consumer and prosumer and then everyone has the option to either use P2S2P or highly-secure direct IP2IP private networks. A simple firmware update by your development team would place the Argus range into a more wider complete market.April 23, 2019 at 4:38 pm #247904
Thank you for your suggestion. Yes, the battery-powered cameras can only be accessed via UID at present, sorry for any inconvenience caused to you. I will forward your suggestion to our R&D staff and we will notify you at the first time as long as there is an update. I know there are still many shortcomings in Reolink, we will strive to make our products more in line with the needs of the customers. Thank you for your understanding.
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.